Almost Cool by Aaron Coleman

Friday, December 12th, 2003

Excerpt: Somehow, the duo (with some help from friends) have packed an amazing amount of dynamic tension into 5 songs and a tight 25 minutes.

The Autumn-Waking
The Loudest Birthday Ever EP
(Tense Forms)

Take two friends and a practice space above a taco joint, mix in a bunch of borrowed equipment and a partially-busted 8-track tape recorder. Stir it all together (during a Midwest winter no less) and amazingly enough the final product is remarkably similar to what you might expect The Loudest Birthday Ever to sound like. At times fragile and at others brutal, it’s the sound of two people working out their thoughts in a place where the weather changes as quick as feelings.

Despite the somewhat auspicious beginning, this little EP drags you along kicking and screaming, but it’s a fun ride to take. The disc opens with super skronky organs and guitars over raining cymbals before the whole thing stumbles forward with a rugged determination and singer Allison Stanley adds clear and pointed vocals over it all. It all drops off to near silence at one point, then comes all slamming back just as you think it’s going to stay all pretty sounding. “Copywright” opens up with a see-saw organ and more warm vocals by Stanley before all hell busts loose again.

“Under The Maude Moon” takes things in a slightly different direction, moving along completely subdued with quiet percussion, guitars and vocals before breaking off into a passage with a field recording. As you may have guessed, it doesn’t stay silent forever, and guitars, organ, and drums all come roaring back in sounding like they’ve been pushed through about 3 compressors too many (in a good way). On “Simulating The Haystack,” Joshua Dumas takes lead vocals and after a slightly over-dramatic opening the track shifts into a beautiful lull before taking off. Mashing influences delightfully, the group sometimes sounds like a cross between Rainer Maria and Slint, while at others they simply sound like that band who makes such a beautiful racket as you drive by the open window of their practice space. Somehow, the duo (with some help from friends) have packed an amazing amount of dynamic tension into 5 songs and a tight 25 minutes. It wanders at times, but always comes back around again, setting up tension perfectly before letting loose with an assault of noise. It’s like a raw and rugged cousin of Emo that wants to move you without aiming for the tearducts.

Rating: 7.75

Splendid E-zine by Ben Hughes

Tuesday, November 25th, 2003

Excerpt: the band scribbles outside the lines while keeping their songs intact. "Under the Maude Moon" drops a battery of jazz drumming and some eerie disembodied voices to great effect, building to a fiery guitar-driven climax.

The Autumn-Waking
The Loudest Birthday Ever EP
Tense Forms

Format Reviewed: CD

The rise of record labels-as-art-collectives is a largely positive development, in my opinion. Throw a bunch of musicians, writers, designers and various creative people together in a room and you’re almost guaranteed to get something interesting. That’s certainly the case with The Autumn-Waking, a product of Chicago’s close-knit Tense Forms family. Like Rainer Maria after four years at RISD, they take a basic emo template and shovel on the art damage with glorious abandon. I’d call this experimental, but I don’t want to scare anyone; on The Loudest Birthday Ever EP, the band scribbles outside the lines while keeping their songs intact. “Under the Maude Moon” drops a battery of jazz drumming and some eerie disembodied voices to great effect, building to a fiery guitar-driven climax. On “To the Wall and Over”, Allison Stanley’s voice dukes it out with Renee Bertsch’s organ for center stage, eventually settling into an uneasy truce. It’s a nice start from a band I hope we’ll be hearing more from soon.
Ben Hughes

Tablet by Catherine P. Lewis

Tuesday, November 11th, 2003

Excerpt: By far, this group's music works best when powerful siren-like vocals transcend the grinding melodies.

the autumn-waking
the loudest birthday ever
Tense Forms
•••••6••••

Once the challenging origami-like packaging of the autumn-waking’s the loudest birthday ever has been conquered, what remains is five songs that tackle some combination of art punk and shoegaze, with varied success. The EP fires off with a driving song reminiscent of Sky Cries Mary, complete with haunting female vocals and trance-inducing repetitive lyrics. From there, however, the energy is lost. The songs become more and more instrumental, and the female vocals disappear almost completely and are replaced by unconvincing male voices and sampled spoken pieces. By far, this group’s music works best when powerful siren-like vocals transcend the grinding melodies. If the singing on the first two tracks is performed by guest S. Renée Bertsch, then permanent autumn-waking members Allison Stanley and Joshua Dumas should consider bringing her into the group full-time. - Catherine P. Lewis

Delusions of Adequacy by Gary

Monday, September 29th, 2003

Excerpt: simple but intense, easily bounding from delicate and lulling to powerful and crunching... The Autumn-Waking have devised another way to inject originality into the two-piece band dynamic. Recommended.

The Autumn-Waking
The Loudest Birthday Ever EP
Tense Forms

File Under: Aggressive shoegazer rock
RIYL: Milemarker, PJ Harvey

It seems that there’s been quite the collection of two-piece bands around the music circuit lately, covering everything from punk and blues to fractured dance music. However, The Autumn-Waking’s The Loudest Birthday Everadds a new twist to the two-piece band dynamic by giving the good old-fashioned garage-rock sound a shoegazer bent. Now in all honesty, The Autumn-Waking does cheat a bit, as this EP sees guest vocalist/organist S. Renee Bertsch joining drummer Allison Stanley and vocalist/guitarist Joshua Dumas for five tracks that turn out surprisingly lush, considering the somewhat sparse musical arrangements involved (Bertsch, it seems, was merely a part of the recording process, and is not actually a regular member of the band).

The main basis of every song here is easily the drumming, which breaks out of the typical ‘minimalist drumming in a two-piece band’ mold, courtesy of Stanley’s inspired playing (which is obviously influenced at least slightly by her past experience with the experimental/free-form jazz project the SILVER measure). Bertsch’s contributions to this EP are major, as her strong vocals are present in every track, and even the minimal, underlying organ pieces in these tracks add immesurable depth to the songs. Still, though, there’s no seling Dumas short, either, as the guitar playing on The Loudest Birthday Ever is simple but intense, easily bounding from delicate and lulling to powerful and crunching, while his vocals drag along from near whispers to Bob Mould reminiscient guttoral moans.

The disc opens with the organ/guitar-fronted, stomp-then-sprawl experience that is “To the Wall and Over,” which is punctuated by some depely spacy guitars. Bertsch’s vocals on this track are to die for - especially when they’re intermingled with Dumas’ primative groans. “Copyright” opens with an awesome combination of organ and female vocals that sounds like a dark, twisted form of church music. Delicate guitars and quite drums build up behind the open until the levee breaks, leaving a trail of crunching guitars and aggressive male/female vocals in its wake.

“Under the Maude Moon” showcases the band’s diversity and musicianship a bit more, as another very nice, soft opening leads to a crazy jazz breakdown that clears out to a stark set-up of echoing guitar to back some incredibly vulnerable-sounding Bertsch vocals. An almost flowery-sounding musical bed backs up a mid-track spoken word soundbyte piece here, though the track does eventually build itself back up to a strong garage-rock pinnacle, complete with just a touch of the shoegazer vibe thrown in. The song’s closing comes when Dumas and Bertsch share a pretty little male/female vocal round that gets a slight bit aggressive. Somewhere around the middle of “Simulating the Haystack,” there’s a sweet instrumental break that builds up into a set of powerful, stop-and-go, quiet to loud rhythmic swells that grind together into a frenzied ending.

“What People Worry About” is The Loudest Birthday Ever‘s epic track, with the first few moments seemingly revolving around the vocal interplay between Bertsch and Dumas. The vocals compliment each other remarkably, as Dumas tends to moan quietly when Bertsch sings strongly, though as soon as his voice turns to yelling and groaning, she pulls her vocals back to a controlled whisper - the effect is has over the song is really something to be heard. The track’s breakdown is possibly the nicest on the disc, and after it breaks into another jazzy freak-out, a picked guitarline floats out behind another set of soundbytes. By the time the track returns to the original ‘chorus’ set-up, the form has been mangled, and what comes out is a thick noise redux.

Considering the simplistic nature of The Autumn-Waking’s musical set-up and compositions, there really is a lot going on during The Loudest Birthday Ever. Stark without being annoyingly sparse, The Autumn-Waking have devised another way to inject originality into the two-piece band dynamic. Recommended.